Answers and Analysis
This knowledge base, updated to include the analyses from the 2003 through the most recent editions of the Uniform Plumbing and Mechanical Codes,
continues to be a premier source for engineers, inspectors, students, contractors and tradesmen. Questions come from a broad base of users, and answers
are informal interpretations of the Codes provided by a committee of code officials and special experts - they are clearly stated and to the point.
This updated site combines the most pertinent analyses from the previous manual and presents them together with those based on the most recent
publications of the Uniform Codes. This makes the Answers and Analysis database one of the most valuable tools you as a member can access wherever you have an internet connection.
The Answers and Analysis tool makes it easy to search for relevant questions and answers, either based on keywords or specific sections/chapters of the code.
To find questions related to specific topics, type in the keyword(s), select the code and the year and click "Search".
To search for questions related to a specific section, type the section in the Section field and click "Search".
To search a specific chapter or appendix, select either the UPC or UMC Table of Contents, and select the chapter/appendix from the list.
Questions matching UPC Chapter 4
80 results
UPC 2003 401.1
UPC 2006 401.1
UPC 2009 401.1
UPC 2012 401.1
Topic: Caulking Bath Units
In the installation of a tub/shower unit, are we correct in requiring the two vertical joints and the horizontal joint just above the tub to be caulked and sealed after installation for sanitary purposes? Would these
joints, if not properly caulked, become “concealed fouling surfaces” as referenced in Section 401.1?
If the bath units are installed in compliance with the manufacturer’s installation instructions and the IAPMO listing, additional caulking to alleviate a potential fouling surface would not be required.
UPC 2003 402.4
UPC 2006 402.4
UPC 2009 402.4
UPC 2012 403.4
1. Are the men's and women's bathrooms in a retail store that are open to the public use required to have metered faucets on lavatories? 2. In state or office buildings where there are central bathrooms (men's and women's) which are intended to serve the transient public, are metered faucets on lavatories required?
3. What does transient mean?
Section 402.4 (2003/2006/2009) 403.4 (2012) references "transient public". In this instance the purpose is to distinguish between one element of the public occupancy and another element. Webster's Ninth Collegiate Dictionary defines transient as "temporary; fleeting; passing quickly.
Metered faucets are required as the concern addressed by the code is the potential for misuse by the transient public which has no vested interest in appropriate utilization of public buildings or their facilities
As opposed to employees who require extended and predictable periods of occupancy.
UPC 2003 403.1
UPC 2006 406.4
UPC 2009 406.4
UPC 2012 407.4
Topic: Zinc Alloy Slip Nuts, Washers, Etc.
1. Does Section 403.1, (2003) 406.4, ( 2006/2009), 407.4 (2012) allow pot metal or coated slip nuts to be used on basket strainers?
2. Does this section allow closet bolt washers and tank-to-bowl washers on water closets?
3. What parts/components does this section have reference to?
1. Yes. Section 403.1 (2003), 406.4, (2006/2009) 407.4 (2012) applies to slip nuts on the bottom of basket strainers, as well as the other slip nuts used to connect fixture tailpieces, continues waste, etc. Zinc alloy components
are acceptable for external use only and are required to comply with their listing.
2. All materials utilized in a plumbing system are expected to comply with the limitations of their listing or
shall be otherwise approved by the local Authority Having Jurisdiction (see Section 301.0). Closet bolt
washers are required to comply with Section 704.4.5 (2003/2006) 408.4.5(2009) 402.3 (2012).
3. Same answer as #2
UPC 2003 404
UPC 2006 403
UPC 2009 403
UPC 2012 404.1
Are overflows required on all plumbing fixtures?
The Code requires overflows for fixtures in one application only; as noted in Section 411.6 (2003) 410.5, (2006/2009) 413.5 (2012), where specific criteria are detailed. Other fixtures having optionally installed overflows are subject to the requirements of Section 404.0.
UPC 2003 405.2
UPC 2006 404.2
UPC 2009 404.2
UPC 2012 402.11
Topic: Bathtub Access Panels
Does Section 405.2 (2003) 404.2, 2006/2009) 402.11 (2012) require a 1 foot by 1 foot tub access opening when solvent cemented joints are used?
No. Section 405.2 (2003) 404.2, (2006/2009) 402.11 (2012) requires access panels or utility space of at least 12 inches in its least dimension for fixtures having concealed slip joint connections. Solvent cemented plastic pipe joints are not slip joint connections. See also 221.0, Slip joint (2003/2006/2009/2012)
UPC 2003 405.3
UPC 2006 404.2
UPC 2009 404.2
UPC 2012 402.11
We request clarification of Section 221.0, Slip Joints and Section 405.2(2003); 404.3 (2006/2009) 402.11 (2012 as to whether or not a tubular bathtub waste and overflow drain is determined to have slip joints based on the language in the Code.
Section 405.3 (2003); 404.3 (2006/2009) 402.11 (2012) requires waste and overflows not constructed of materials specified in Section 701.0 (Schedule 40, etc.) be exposed or accessible regardless of whether the joint is considered a slip joint or not a slip joint. The waste and overflows do, in fact, fall under the requirements of Section 405.2 (2003) 404.2, (2006/2009), 402.11(2012) for slip joint connections and Section 405.3 (2003); 404.3, (2006/2009) 420.3 (2012) because they are tubular material and must be accessible.
UPC 2003 406.4
UPC 2006 401.1
UPC 2009 401.1
UPC 2012 401.1
Topic: Concealed Fouling Surfaces
A question has been raised about the underside of stone countertops when the sinks are attached below or under the countertops. There is 1⁄2" or more of the edge that creates an overhang into the sink bowl area.
Does this edge or overhang meet the definition of a fouling edge or surface as per Section 406.4 (2003) 401.1, (2006/2009/2012)?
No. The area described would not be considered a concealed fouling surface.
UPC 2003 408.2
UPC 2006 407.2
UPC 2009 407.2
UPC 2012 402.2
1. Where a wall-hung lavatory abuts a smooth non-porous wall, does the joint require caulking? 2. Does a floor-mounted water closet require caulking around the base at the perimeter intersection with the floor?
The answer to both questions is yes. Section 408.2 (2003) 407.2, (2006/2009) 402.2 (2012) refers to those parts of the perimeter of any fixed plumbing fixture which make contact with either a wall or a floor and are normally subject to splash or wetting. This universally applied sanitary concept is also intended to prevent structural damage from water penetration.
UPC 2003 408.3
UPC 2006 407.3
UPC 2009 407.3
UPC 2012 402.6.2
Topic: Securing of Fixtures
Are brass plated closet bolts acceptable?
The Product Certification Committee maintains that closet tank or bowl accessories shall be manufactured
of a non-ferrous metal. This excludes the use of brass plated steel bolts or any other type of plated ferrous
metal. The terms equally corrosion resistant material in Section 408.3 (2003) 407.3 (2006/2009) 402.6.2 (2012) and noncorrosive in Section 408.4 (2003) 407.4 (2006/2009) 402.4 (2012) are used as general terms. It was never the intent of the Code to establish parameters of acceptable corrosion resistance for copper versus copper alloy, versus stainless steel, etc. By eliminating the use of ferrous metal (plated or not) for closet bolts, nuts, and washers, a reasonably long service life can be expected.
UPC 2003 408.6
UPC 2006 407.6
UPC 2009 407.5
UPC 2012 402.5
Topic: Setting of Fixtures
Section 408.6 (2003) 407.6 (2006) 407.5 (2009) 402.5 (2012) states that the minimum sidewall clearance for water closet or bidet is 15 inches. The same minimum clearance for a urinal is 12 inches. Is there a requirement for a lavatory or drinking fountain?
Section 309.0 (2003/2006/2009) 308.1 (2012) stipulates that fixtures may not be located in a manner which interferes with the "normal use thereof". Section 310.1 (2003/2006/2009) 309.1 (2012) notes that all "design, construction, and workmanship" shall satisfy the intent of the Code. Section 408.6 (2003) 407.6 (2006); 407.5, (2009) 402.5 (2012) offers specific spacing for water closets and bidets with proximity to side walls, obstructions, or similar fixtures. The sum total of these code sections is to allow considerable design latitude while noting specific accessibility requirements and standard practices which are intended to guide both the designer and the installer regarding appropriate location and spacing of adjacent fixtures. In summary, the code provides minimum spacing for water closets, bidets, and urinals. Other fixtures are spaced at the discretion of the designer with installation input provided by the manufacturer (see Section 310.4, 2003/2006/2009) 309.4 (2012).
Note: There are, however, federal regulations for handicapped accessibility that may apply to both of these
fixtures..
UPC 2003 409.1
UPC 2006 408.1
UPC 2009 408.1
UPC 2012 411.2.1
Topic: Water Closets for Public Use
Sections 409.1 and 409.2.2 (2003) 408.1 and 408.2.2 (2006/2009) 411.2.1 (2012) require that water closet bowls for public use be elongated bowls equipped with open front seats. Does this apply to a building which may have many employees, but which does not provide facilities for the walk-in public?
Yes. Section 218.0 (2003/2006/2009/2012), Private or Private Use, defines private as including only “a family or an individual.” A family is commonly defined as a group of persons related by blood or marriage. Water
closets used by any group consisting of other than members of a single family or an individual would therefore be considered as public usage, as defined in Section 218.0 (2003/2006/2009/2012), Public or Public Use, and would therefore be required to be elongated bowls with open front seats.
UPC 2003 412.1
UPC 2006 411.1
UPC 2009 411.1
UPC 2012 418.2
Topic: Shower Drain Fittings
Please explain what is meant by "suitably flanged to provide a water-tight joint in the floor." Is this specifically regarding shower drains that are built-up or otherwise? What if the floor drain is installed in a concrete slab on a ground floor? Is a flanged drain still required?
The UPC requires all floor mounted fixtures (floor drains, shower drains, floor sinks, etc.) to be "suitably flanged," which equates to be "double-flanged." The top flange provides sufficient surface area that is large enough to accommodate strainer openings
(equivalent to the area of the tailpiece).
The bottom flange is a designed feature and is intended to prevent leakage which passes the top
flange from wetting the ceiling of the floor level below.
Shower receptors installed at any floor level above the "slab on grade" level are required the have an
additional clamping ring on the bottom flange. This ring allows the lining material to be secured and pitched
"to the weep holes in the subdrain."
UPC 2003 413.3
UPC 2006 412.3
UPC 2009 412.3
UPC 2012 422.2
Topic: Separate Facilities
Does Exception 2 in Section 412.3, Separate Facilities, apply to Business and Mercantile occupancies?
Yes, exception 2 found in Section 412.3, would apply to all types of occupancies serving 10 or fewer people.
UPC 2003 413.3
UPC 2006 412.3
UPC 2009 412.3
UPC 2012 422.2
Topic: Separate Facilities
Would a restaurant (a business that sells food to be consumed on the premises)with a total floor area less than 1,500 square feet be allowed to comply with 2009 UPC Section 412.3 exception (3) and be constructed with only a unisex restroom or will restrooms for each sex be required?
Section 412.3 of the 2009 UPC requires the installation of separate toilet facilities with three exceptions. Exception two (2), which states, “in occupancies serving ten (10) or fewer people, one (1) toilet facility, designed for use by no more than one (1) person at a time, shall be permitted for the use of both sexes”, would apply to all occupancies including restaurants.
No, exception #3 applies to business and mercantile occupancies only. The category that applies to your application is restaurants which requires restroom facilities for both male and female. A restaurant is not a business and mercantile occupancy.
(at 30 sq ft per person a 1500 sq ft restaurant would have an occupant load of 50)
UPC 2003 412.7
UPC 2006 411.7
UPC 2009 411.7
UPC 2012 408.6
Topic: Determining Minimum Size of Showers
How do you determine the minimum interior dimensions of a shower?
The measurements are taken at a height equal to the top of the threshold and from finish wall to finish wall,
or finish wall to the centerline of the threshold. All shower compartments must have a minimum finished
interior of 1,024 square inches and be capable of encompassing a 30 inch circle.
UPC 2003 412.8
UPC 2006 411.8
Topic: Shower Receptors Built on Ground
We would appreciate your interpretation of Section 412.8 (1) (2003) 411.8 [1],( 2006), “Shower Receptors Built Directly on the Ground.” Specifically, for concrete slab-on-grade floor construction, would a shower which is built directly on this concrete slab be considered to be built directly on the ground or above ground?
In Section 412.8 (1) (2003; 411.8 (1), 2006; 411.8, 2009), shower receptors built directly on the ground means qualifying monolithic poured-in-place or equivalent receptors conforming to the basic plumbing
fixture requirements of Section 401.0, complete with integral threshold, sides and back, directly supported
by the underlying ground.
The sides and back must extend at least three inches above the finished threshold before any wood
superstructure or wall covering may be added.
In Section 412.8 (2) (2003; 411.8 (2), 2006; 411.8, 2009), “shower receptors built above ground” constitute
the majority of site-built receptors and are built up over an approved sloping sub-base which may be
part of a concrete slab floor when constructed as prescribed in Section 412.8 (2) (2003; 411.8 (2), 2006;
411.8, 2009) and elsewhere in Sections 401.0 and 412.0(2003) 411.0, (2006/2009). Such receptors require
approved linings pitched 1/4 inch per foot to weep holes in conforming subdrains.
UPC 2003 412.8 (1)
UPC 2006 411.8(1)
Topic: Shower Receptors Built on Ground
1. Are shower pans or liners required for showers built directly on the ground? 2. Does the word approved in Section 412.8 (1)(2003) (411.8 [1], 2006) mean listed for the use?
Section 412.8 (2003) 411.8(1), 2006; (411.8), 2009) provides, when permitted by the Authority Having Jurisdiction, a method of construction for shower receptors to be built directly on the ground without a pan or liner. Shower receptor built directly on the ground means qualifying monolithic poured-in-place receptors
conforming to the basic plumbing fixtures requirements in Section 412.0 (2003) 411.0, (2006/2009), complete with integral threshold, sides and back, directly supported by the underlying ground.
UPC 2003 413.3
UPC 2006 412.3
UPC 2009 412.3
UPC 2012 422.2
Topic: Separate Facilities
Section 413.3 (2003) 412.3, (2006/2009) 422.2 (2012), exception 3 allows a single unisex facility to serve
This exception does not give minimum restroom facilities requirements based on the occupant load but, instead, on the square footage of the space in question. A single unisex restroom would be allowed in any business or mercantile with a maximum of fifteen-hundred (1,500) square feet, regardless of the number of employees or customers.
UPC 2003 413.5.3
UPC 2006 412.5.3
UPC 2009 412.5.3
Topic: Restrooms Required
Is it the intent of the code to require a store with a floor area that is greater than 150 square feet to be provided with a restroom? If so, please provide a case where this code provision is applicable.
Stores with floor areas greater than 150 square feet may be served by centrally located public restroom facilities with a 500 foot maximum path of travel. Stores less than 150 square feet in area (e.g., photos
stands, candy vendors, hot dog vendors, jewelry marts and kiosks) that normally operate in the middle of
a mall, are required to be located within 300 feet of such public restroom facilities.
UPC 2006 414.5
UPC 2009 414.5
UPC 2012 408.3
Topic: Limitations on Bathtubs
Does section 414.5 (2006/2009) 409.4(2012) apply to a claw foot type bathtub with a fixed shower riser/curtain for a stand-up type shower? Or is section 418.0 (2006/2009) 408.3 (2012) applicable for such an installation?
Section 418.0 (2006/2009) 408.3 (2012) would apply for a tub-shower combination. Both section requires that a maximum temperature of one hundred (120) degree Fahrenheit to prevent protection from scalding. The difference is the need for a shower or tub-shower combination having conforming to ASSE 1016 or ASME A112.18.11CSA B125.1 that would protect for scalding but also for thermal shock, caused from rapid temperature change.
UPC 2006 414.5
UPC 2009 414.5
UPC 2012 409.4
Topic: Shower and tub-shower combination control valves
When a combination tub/shower valve, listed to ASSE 1016, and installed only as tub filler, does this comply with UPC Section 414.5?
Temperature limiting valves for bathtubs and whirlpool tubs shall meet the requirements of ASSE 1070 or CSA B125.3 as prescribed in Section 414.5 of the 2009 UPC. The difference between the two devices is; a 1016 device can be a pressure balance, thermostatic mixing or combination pressure balance and thermostatic mixing valve. A 1070 device is thermostatic mixing valve only. A 1016 device is required on shower or tub/shower combination valves to prevent thermal shock when standing in the water under the showerhead. A 1070 device is allowed in section 414.5 because the thermal shock issue is eliminated when the water from the tub filler mixes with the water in the tub. A person is not standing directly under the water coming from a tub spout and is not subject to thermal shock.
Please consult the AHJ in your jurisdiction to see if they would allow the installation described.
UPC 2003 416
UPC 2006 415
UPC 2009 415
UPC 2012 417.5
Topic: Hot Water Orientation
Does Section 416.0 (2003) 415.0 (2006/2009) 417.5 (2012) require the hot water supply piping to be on the left side of the fixtures, or does this section apply solely to the required placement of the hot water control valve?
Section 416.0 (2003) 415.0 (2006/2009) 417.5 (2012) requires that the hot water be connected to the left side of the faucet or diverter; there is no orientation requirement for piping, existing walls, floors, or ceilings.
UPC 2003 420
UPC 2006 418
UPC 2009 418
UPC 2012 409.4
Topic: Requirement for Pressure Balance or Thermostatic Control Mixing Valves
Does Section 420.0 (2003) 418.0 (2006/2009) 409.4 (2012) apply to bathtubs and roman tubs with no shower?
No. Section 420.0 (2003) 418.0 (2006/2009) 409.4 (2012)clearly states that only showers and tub-shower combinations fall under this requirement. Section 414.5 was added in 2009, 408.3 (2012) and now requires bathtub and whirlpool tub fillers to limit hot water to 120 degrees by a device that conforms to ASSE 1070 or CSA B125.3
UPC 2003 420
UPC 2006 418
UPC 2009 418
UPC 2012 409.4
Topic: Hand-Held Shower for Whirlpool
Does a whirlpool tub equipped with a deck mounted hand-held shower unit have to comply with Section 420.0 (2003) 418.0 (2006/2009) 409.4 (2012)?
Section 420.0 (2003) 418.0 (2006/2009) 409.4 (2012) is applicable solely to installations where a stand-up shower enclosure is combined with the bathing facilities. Section 415.5 414.5 was added in 2009 408.3 (2012) and now requires bathtub and whirlpool tub fillers to limit hot water to 120 degrees by a device that conforms to ASSE 1070 or CSA B125.3
UPC 2003 601.3
UPC 2006 601.3
UPC 2009 601.3
UPC 2012 417.5
Topic: Right-Left Orientation of Bathtub Faucets
Section 601.3 (2003/2006/2009), 417.5 (2012) states that “faucets and diverters shall be connected to the water distribution system so that hot water corresponds to the left side of the fittings.” There is no mention of where the person stands in relation to the fittings. If I were standing on the outside of an island tub, where should the hot be? I can operate the faucet from outside or inside the tub.
The left side of a faucet is determined when the operator is positioned inside of the fixture (tub, shower, etc.) facing the control valves.
UPC 2003 704.4.5
UPC 2006 704.4.5
UPC 2009 408.4.5
UPC 2012 402.6.2
Topic: Securing Closet Rings
Section 704.0 (2003/2006/2009/2012) addresses floor flanges. We have been requiring plastic floor flanges to be screwed to the subfloor. Subsection 704.4.3 (2003/2006), 408.4.3 (2009) 402.6.0 (2012) states that they must be screwed or fastened in an approved manner. Some inspectors are requiring these screws to be of brass. Subsection 704.4.5 (2003/2006) 408.4.5 (2009) 402.6.2 (2012) states that closet screws, bolts and washers must be of brass, copper, or equally corrosion resistant material. My question is, do these same materials apply to screws used to secure the flange to the floor or could cadmium or plain steel screws be used?
The purpose of using brass, copper or other approved corrosion resistant screws or bolts to secure fixtures is to minimize the possibility of failure which could cause the fixture to come loose. This applies equally if
the flange is fastened to other materials or fastened directly to the floor. Materials which are not corrosion resistant are not approved for securing flanges.
UPC 2009 411.6
UPC 2012 408.5
Is a permanent, 2" dam, curb or threshold required in a residential (non-accessible) shower?
No, Section 411.6 (2006/2009), 408.5 (2012) Finished Curb or Threshold applies only to showers that have finished curbs or thresholds.
Comment: This Section applies to manufactured shower bases that have curbs or thresholds and contains no requirements for curbless showers except for exception #1, accessible showers. We think the intent of the code change was to allow curbless showers without the shower having to meet all the requirements of ADA. Because the code has no requirements for a curbless shower, other than ADA requirements, we feel that a curbless shower, not meeting ADA, would have to be submitted for approval as an alternate method of construction per section 301.2.
UPC 2003 412.4
UPC 2009 411.4
UPC 2012 418.5
Does this code section mean that the entire floor area shall slope from walls to drain(s)? Should slope be 1/4"/foot?
The entire floor surface is required to be sloped to the floor drain(s). However, there is no minimum slope for the floor mentioned in the code. Only floors within a shower enclosure require a minimum 1/4”/ft. Slope.
UPC 2009 403.0; 409.3
UPC 2012 404.0 ; 409.3
UPC 2015 404.0 ;409.3
Does UPC require all bathtubs to be equipped with an overflow? If so, what section?
The Standards for fixtures listed in Table 1401.1 (2009/2012), Table 1701.1 (2015) all indicate that overflows are required on bathtubs and whirlpool bathtubs. These same Standards indicate that the overflow requirements are optional for sinks, lavatories and bidets. If an overflow is provided with a fixture, section 403.0 (2009); 404.0 (2012/2015) shall be followed for proper installation. Section 409.3 is referring the installer to section 403.0 (2009); 404.0 (2012/2015) to guide the installer on how to pipe the overflow that is provided on a Bathtub or whirlpool bathtub.
UPC 2009 Table 4-1
UPC 2012 422.1
UPC 2015 422.1
Section 422.1 states that the building occupancy classification and load shall be determined by the building code and that plumbing fixtures shall be provided for the type of building occupancy shown in Table 4-1 (2009); Table 422.1 (2012/2015). If the building has multiple occupancies and the building code requires each portion of the building to be individually classified by the type of occupancy or use, are the number of plumbing fixtures determined separately by each classification according to the Table and then summed?
For example, according to the building code there is a building for professional services classified as B occupancy. Within the building there are two accessory occupancies; One is a mercantile gift shop classified by the building code as M occupancy, and the other is a large space rented out for storage classified by the building code as S occupancy. When using Table 4-1 (2009); Table 422.1 (2012/2015), is the number of plumbing fixtures determined first by the occupant load for each classification as determined by the building code and then summed, or can the number of plumbing fixtures be determined only by the primary use of the building, which in this case is B occupancy although the building code has classified it as multiple occupancies?
If each space is to have its own restroom(s) the occupant load for that space would be used along with the corresponding classification to determine the minimum required fixtures. If a common restroom facility is desired, the combination of the two occupant loads should be used and the classification requiring the higher number of fixtures per number of occupants used.
UPC 2009 418
UPC 2012 408.3
UPC 2015 408.3
Topic: Shower and Tub and Shower Control Valves
When replacing the water distribution system of an existing apartment complex, would it be required to replace the shower valve with pressure balancing tub/shower valves?
Pressure balancing shower valves became a code requirement in the 1997 edition of the UPC.
Section 101.5.3 (2009), 101.11.2 (2012), 102.2 (2015) does not require fixtures, such as the shower valves in your question, to the current standards unless the valves are being replaced. Replacement valves would need to meet current codes and standards per sections 418.0 (2009); 408.3 (2012/2015).
UPC 2009 404.3
UPC 2012 405.2
UPC 2015 701.4
Topic: 3-Compartment Sink
Would a 1 1/2" double tee be allowed to combine the three compartments of a three compartment sink?
A three compartment sink is a single fixture and the connections between the individual compartments are by definition a continuous waste. The code does not have specific requirements for the type of fittings that may be used on a continuous waste, although the Code does require a wye or other directional type fitting when a disposal unit is connected to the continuous waste. Although there may not be a specific requirement the committee feels that a double fixture fitting or a double combination makes a better installation. For the requirements in your area contact the AHJ to find out their requirements.
UPC 2009 412.3 Exception 3
UPC 2012 422.2 Exception 3
UPC 2015 422.2 Exception 3
Topic: Separate Facilities
Is the intent of Section 412.3 Exception 3 (2009), 422.2 Exception 3 (2012/ 2015) to also exempt the required male urinal fixture in Table 4-1 (2009), Table 422.1(2012/ 2015)?
Is the intent of the code when providing a one-person toilet facility to exempt the required urinal?
Yes. The intent of this section is to allow a single toilet facility, serving both male and female, in business and mercantile occupancies where the total occupant load is fewer than 50. Types of occupancies other than business and mercantile requiring urinals per Table 4-1 (2009), Table 422.1 (2012/2015) would be required to install urinals even if the occupant load is less than 50.
UPC 2009 411.6
UPC 2012 408.5
UPC 2015 408.5
Topic: Shower Finished Curb or Threshold
Does a shower receptor that complies with ANSI/ICC A117 have to meet any of the conditions in Section 411.6 (2009), 408.5(2012/2015)?
Yes. Section 411.6 Exception (2009), 408.5 Exception 1 (2012/ 2015) is to allow for the accessibility standards to be met in regards to shower receptors to allow a shower with no threshold so that a wheelchair can roll into the shower. Slope to the drain and waterproofing at the walls would still be required.
Note: Section 408.5 in the 2015 UPC has added language that states the immediate adjoining space to showers without thresholds shall be considered a wet location and shall comply with the requirements of the building, residential and electrical codes.
UPC 2009 412.3 ; Table 4-1
UPC 2012 422.2(2) ; Table 422.1
UPC 2015 422.2(2) ; Table 422.1
Topic: Separate Facilities
Does a unisex restroom in a B occupancy with an occupant load of less than 10 require a urinal in addition to the water closet?
No. A urinal would not be required for a (B) occupancy of 10 or less persons.
UPC 2009 402.5
UPC 2012 416.0
UPC 2015 416.0
Topic: Emergency Eyewash and Shower Equipment
Does the UPC require or refer to ASSE 1071 mixing valves used in emergency eyewash and shower equipment?
Section 402.5 (2009), 416.0 (2012/ 2015) references emergency eyewash and shower equipment, but no reference to ASSE 1071.
Section 416.0 (2012/ 2015) requires the water supply rates, discharge pattern and temperature of flushing fluids be in accordance with ISEA Z358.1. This standard does specify the use of tepid water (defined therein as water at a temperature between 60 and 100 degrees), but does not reference the type of device that should be installed to accomplish that requirement. Table 1401.1 (2012), Table 1701.1 (2015) does reference ASSE 1071-2012 for Temperature Actuated Mixing Valves for Plumbed Emergency Equipment.
UPC 2009 411.8.1
UPC 2012 408.7.1
UPC 2015 408.7.5
Topic: Tests for Shower Receptors
Is a shower without a threshold required to have a test such as ADA showers? Is a temporary dam to fill the receptor for test in accordance with this section?
The code does not separate the testing of an ADA shower installation and a typical shower with a curb or threshold. If constructed correctly, even an ADA compliant “roll-in shower” would have a high point at the entrance of the shower enclosure. All areas of this “enclosure” would be have to be verified as “water-tight” as required by the code.
UPC 2009 807.4
UPC 2012 414.3, 807.4
UPC 2015 414.3, 807.3
Topic: Dishwasher Drainage Connection
When installing new or replacing a domestic dishwasher are there any exceptions to the requirement of having "an approved dishwasher air gap fitting on the discharge side of a dishwashing machine”?
In Section 414.3 (2012/2015), domestic dishwashing machines shall discharge indirectly through an air gap fitting in accordance with Section 807.4 (2009/2012), 807.3 (2015) into a waste receptor, a wye branch fitting on the tailpiece of a kitchen sink, or a dishwasher connection of a food waste grinder.
Per the code there are no exceptions.
Some Authorities Having Jurisdiction may grant deviations when existing dishwashers are being replaced.
UPC 2006 417.0
UPC 2012 402.12
UPC 2015 402.11
Based on the language in 402.12, "the plumbing system for such fixtures shall be complete". Would a future lower level bath in a new home (toilet, shower or tub and lav) require all DWV be completed, including the venting for the future fixtures?
Yes, if the system is piped to a point where a fixture trap is to be installed per Section 402.12 of the 2012 UPC, “…the plumbing system for such fixture shall be complete and be in accordance with the plumbing requirements of this code”.
UPC 2006 411.6
UPC 2012 408.5
UPC 2015 408.5
Topic: Finished Curb or Threshold
I would like to do barrier-free/curbless showers but was told we are required to have at minimum 2" from top the shower threshold to the drain.
I’ve seen showers that have no threshold in hospitals. If 2” is required why are they not required in those locations. Is there some exception? Is so can you direct me to it?
Comment: We’ve been told to either get a 2" curb OR step down 2" into the shower to satisfy the plumbing code. OR a combination of both: 1" curb and 1" step down for example. We need to eliminate the threshold so that it'll accommodate "universal design" and it'll be more readily accessible.
Exception (1) of Section 408.5 of the 2015 UPC permits the installation of showers without thresholds if the “showers are designed to be in accordance with the accessibility standards listed in Table 1701.1”.
UPC 2012 416.0
UPC 2015 416.0
Does Section 416.1 require tepid water be installed at Emergency Eyewash and shower EQUIPMENT?
Comment:
We believe it doesn't and in fact Z358.1 warns about hot or warm water may accelerate some chemical reactions. This is a copy of a Statement regarding water temperature.
Yes, Section 416.1 of the 2012 UPC specifically states, “Emergency eyewash and shower equipment shall comply with ISEA Z358.1. Section 416.2 states in part that the flow rates, discharge patterns, and temperature of the flushing fluids shall be provided in accordance with ISEA Z358.1. Section 4.5.6 of ISEA Z358.1 states, ”Deliver tepid flushing fluid. In circumstances where chemical reaction is accelerated by flushing fluid temperature, a facilities safety/health advisor should be consulted for the optimum temperature for each application.” Tepid is defined as water at a temperature between 60°F (16°C) and 100°F (38°C).
UPC 2009 407.5
UPC 2012 402.5
UPC 2015 402.5
UPC 2018 402.5
1. Can the 24” clear space in front of a water closet encroach 6 inches into a zero transition shower floor?
2. Is this acceptable as long as the shower does not have a firm barrier or glazing?
Comment:
Without a front barrier to the shower, I'm looking for an opinion on encroaching into a zero transition (damless) shower.
This design in constricted in an existing CMU bathroom.
1. Yes. The intent of Section 402.5 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code has been met since there are no barriers within the required clear space. The requirements of the code section states that “the clear space in front of the water closet, lavatory, or bidet shall not be less than 24 inches.”
2. Yes. See Answer 1.
UPC 2009 412.1, Table 4-1
UPC 2012 422.0, Table 422.1
UPC 2015 422.0, Table 422.1
UPC 2018 422.0, Table 422.1
Topic: Privacy Partitions in public restrooms
Does the Uniform Plumbing Code require privacy partitions in public restrooms?
No. The Uniform Plumbing Code does not require privacy partitions to be installed in public restrooms, even for multiple occupancy facilities. The building code does however have requirements to provide privacy partitions when more than one person can occupy the restroom facility. Installations, such as single user or family toilet facilities, a privacy partition between the toilet and urinal would not be necessary since only one person can occupy the facility.
UPC 2009 407.5
UPC 2012 402.5
UPC 2015 402.5
UPC 2018 402.5
Given: No water closet to be set closer than 15 inches from its center to sidewall or obstruction...
1. What is an obstruction?
2. What is the intent of this code section with regard to obstruction?
3. In residential, would the lavatory counter top that hangs past the side wall of the cabinet be considered a obstruction?
4. Do you measure off the cabinet for the sidewall measurement?
5. Is a Banjo shelf that continues over the water closet an obstruction?
1. The term obstruction is not defined in the Uniform Plumbing Code, but a generic definition of the word “is a thing that impedes or prevents passage or progress; an obstacle or blockage”.
2. The purpose of the requirements found in Section 402.5 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code, is to provide minimum clearances from walls and other fixtures for the installation of water closets.
3. By the strictest interpretation of Section 402.5, any object that protrudes within the 30 inch clear space required for a water closet would be an obstruction.
4. Per Section 402.5, “No water closet or bidet shall be set closer than 15 inches from its center to a side wall or obstruction or closer than 30 inches center to center to a similar fixture.”
5. No. The clearance measurements found in Section 402.5 are intended to provide adequate space for the use of the fixture. A shelf on the wall behind the fixture, which does not extend beyond the water closet tank, is not considered an obstruction.
UPC 2015 422.1, Table 422.1
Topic: Minimum Plumbing Facilities
Am I correct, in my interpretation below, of Section 422.1 and the use of Table 422.1?
Comment:
We need to determine the number of fixtures for a building with multiple occupancies using shared facilities between the occupancies for 50% males and 50% females.
The building has a Group B occupancy of 166 people and a Group A-2 occupancy of 42 people, so we calculate there would be 83 males and 83 females for Group B and 21 males and 21 females for Group A-2.
When determining the number of water closets for males, we calculate the fraction of water closets required for both
Group B and Group A-2 and sum them together before rounding up to the nearest whole number. Thus, 1.66 water closets would be required for Group B and 0.21 water closets would be required for A-2. These numbers would sum to 1.84 and then be rounded up to 2.
This should mean that 2 water closets are required for males. The numbers are not be rounded before being added as this would require 2 water closets for Group B and 1 water closet for Group A-2, resulting in 3 water closets.
I have attached a table of calculated fixture counts based on the occupant loads listed above for both males and females.
No. The 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code does not give specific guidelines on how to calculate multiple occupancies within a structure using a single set of restroom facilities. The committee feels that an acceptable way to calculate a reasonable fixture count is to total the occupant loads, divide those numbers in half in this case 104 male and 104 female. Using Table 422.1 select the applicable occupancy that requires the most fixtures, in this case the B Occupancy and apply the corresponding fixture count.
Example: 104 Male – 104 Female
Men 3 WC, 2 Urn, 2 Lav
Female 8 WC, 3 Lav
Add. Fixtures 2 DF and 1 service sink
UPC 2018 410.0 & Table 702.1
Are bidets permitted in a public restroom?
Comment:
We have a restaurant that would like to install a bidet within each of the Men’s and Women’s restrooms. Our plan checkers are questioning the DASH under Table 702.1 for a bidet for Public and Assembly and are wondering if the UPC is stipulating they are not allowed in those occupancies?
Though the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code does not specifically prohibit the use of bidets in public restrooms, neither Table 610.3 (Water Supply Fixture Units and Minimum Fixture Branch Pipe Sizes) nor Table 702.1(Drainage Fixture Unit Values) have numerical values in the “public” or “assembly” columns for the fixture. This implies that the public installation of bidets would not be applicable.
UPC 2018 408.3, 409.4
Topic: Individual Shower and Tub-Shower Combination Control Valves
1. Does the maximum temperature of 120°F (referenced in sections 408.3 and 409.4) apply to steam delivered for steam showers and/or steam rooms?
2. If steam temperature is not addressed in the code, is an outlet temperature of 125°F permitted for steam showers and/or steam rooms?
1. No. The maximum temperature of 120° F referenced in Sections 408.3 and 409.4 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC) applies only for shower and tub-shower valves and bathtub and whirlpool bathtub filler valves. The UPC does not address the installation of steam showers or steam rooms.
2. Steam cannot be generated until water reaches a temperature of 212°F. Steam generators and related equipment should be installed to the manufacturer’s recommendation.
UPC 2015 402.6.1 & 402.6.2
Topic: Securing Closet Flanges
1. Can we find where the UPC specifically says the top of the Closet Flange needs to be 1/4" above finish floor.
Comment:
In the 2012 UPC Appendix I IS 5-2006 Section 2.3.2 It says the closet flange shall be securely fasten to the floor with the top of the flange 1/4" above finish floor
Section 402.6.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code, addresses the requirements for closet rings (closet flanges). The only mention of flange thickness in that section refers to caulked-on closet rings that shall be one-quarter (1/4”) of an inch thick.
UPC 2012 409.4
Topic: Limitation of Hot Water in Bathtubs and Whirlpool Bathtubs
Please review the attached information of a fixture fitting.
1. Is this floor mount tub filler with hand spray required to conform to ASSE 1016/CSA B125.1 or ASSE 1070/CSA B125.3?
Section 1.2, in the scope of ASSE 1016/CSA B125.1 states that the “standard covers automatic compensating valves intended to control the water temperature to wall or ceiling mounted, hand-held showers; shower heads; body sprays either in individual shower or tub/shower combination fittings; and tub spouts when part of tub/shower combination fittings. The hand held shower for the Delta T4759-FL is clearly not intended to be secured to a wall or ceiling and would therefore not require the control valve to meet the provisions found in ASSE 1016/CSA B125.1.
The faucet would however have to be listed by an approved third party certification/testing agency and be installed to meet the requirements found in Section 409.4 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code, which requires the water for a bathtub and whirlpool bathtub filler to be limited to 120°F by a device that complies with ASSE 1070/ASME A112.1070/CSA B125.70.
UPC 2015 411.3
Topic: Water Closet Seats
Please provide interpretation or clarification of Plumbing Code Section 411.3 with regard to electric hygienic water closet seats.
Comment:
Section 411.3 does not cover Bidet Water Closet seats or Washlets(trademark). For a commercial office or a public use restroom, how do Washlets fit into this code section?
See attached spec sheet and R&T file for the product in question.
I'm trying to confirm if Washlets can be used in a commercial setting even though it is not covered in this section of the code.
The installation of personal hygiene devices for water closets is not addressed in the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), and would therefore not be code compliant without approval by the Authority Having Jurisdiction. The installation requirements of these devices was first introduced into the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code. Section 411.4 of that document states “water closets with integral personal hygiene devices shall comply with ASME A112.4.2/CSA B45.16 - Personal Hygiene Devices for Water Closets. The title and scope of this standard suggests that these devices are intended to be used for private not public installations.
UPC 2015 422.0
Topic: Minimum Number of Required Fixtures
1. Are toilet facilities for housekeeping or other employees required to be provided on the upper floor of guest room?
2. If so does section 422.4.1 apply?
3. Are additional toilet facilities required to be provided at the hotel’s roof deck terrace area which is accessible only to hotel guests?
4. Does Section 422.4.1 apply to Shopping Malls and Centers or to all multi-story commercial buildings including hotels?
Comment:
Building is a 5 story type R-1 occupancy hotel with 164 guest rooms.
Please note that employee toilet facilities are already provided on the main floor level.
1. Toilet facilities for employees, per Section 422.4 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code, require a maximum travel distance of 500 feet and no more than one vertical floor between facilities (422.4.1).
2. Yes.
3. Yes. If the roof terrace is being used as a restaurant or lounge it would be considered an A-2 Occupancy and would have to meet the requirements found in Table 422.1. Uses other than those for an A-2 Occupancy would require facilities with a travel distance of no more than 500 feet and not to exceed one vertical story.
4. Section 422.4.1 applies to all multi-story buildings
UPC 2018 422.4.1
Topic: Access to Toilet Facilities
1. In a multi-story building is it permissible to group required bathroom facilities on alternating floors as long as the total occupant load for both floors is used to determine the required fixture type and quantity?
Yes. The minimum number of fixtures required shall be determined by applying the requirements found in Section 422.1 and Table 422.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code. Section 422.4.1 states that “in multi-story buildings, accessibility to the required toilet facilities shall not exceed one vertical story”. Additionally, Section 422.4 requires toilet facilities for employees and customers in other than shopping malls or centers shall have a maximum travel distance not to exceed 500 feet.
UPC 2015 422.1
Topic: Minimum Plumbing Facilities
We have a design of an office building with 100 occupants on the 5th floor, and 100 occupants on the 6th floor, a total of 200 occupants. We are providing bathrooms on the 5th floor that contain 2 female toilets, a female lavatory, 1 male toilet, one male urinal and one male lavatory. We are providing bathrooms on the 6th floor that contain 2 female toilets, a female lavatory, 1 male toilet, one male urinal and one male lavatory.
Do the bathrooms, even though they are located on alternate floors provide sufficient plumbing fixtures to satisfy the occupant load for the 5th and 6th floor?
No. It is plausible that each floor of the building could be occupied by a different tenant, thereby restricting accessibility of restrooms on one floor by tenants occupying other floors within the building. For this reason, each floor in your example, would be required to have the minimum plumbing facilities per Table 422.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code. The minimum plumbing facilities for your example:
B Occupancy - Office
100 Occupants per floor – 50 Male, 50 Female
Male, 1-WC, 1-UR, 1–Lav.
Female, 3-WC, 1 –Lav.
1- Drinking Fountain, 1-service sink or laundry tub
Note: Multi-story buildings, where accessibility to toilet facilities would not be restricted, may utilize the requirements found in Section 422.4.1 for installing facilities on every other floor.
UPC 2015 422.1
Topic: Minimum Plumbing Facilities
This is a follow-up to UPC 20-16.
The bathrooms are within common corridor areas of the building accessible to any tenant. Is the answer still NO when this is the condition?
There are two Code approved options for the installation of the minimum required restroom facilities in an office building.
1) Accessible restrooms installed on every floor of an office building, per Section 422.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code.
Determine the total occupancy load for the floor using the building code, divide the occupancy by two (half male, half female), using Table 422.1, use the associated fixture count for “B” Occupancy to establish the minimum plumbing facilities required.
2) Accessible restroom facilities on every other floor of an office building, per Section 422.4.1.
Determine the total occupancy load for each floor using the building code, divide by two (half male, half female), using Table 422.1, use the associated fixture count for “B” Occupancy to establish the minimum plumbing facilities required.
UPC 2015 415.2
Topic: Drinking Fountain Alternatives
1. Is it correct that, where food is consumed indoors (like restaurants or cafes) water stations are permitted to replace drinking fountains 1 for 1 (100%) - this applies only to food establishments?
2. Is it correct that, bottle filling stations are permitted to be substituted 1 for every 2 required (50%) - this applies to all occupancies and throughout all buildings?
3. Is it correct that, drinking fountains are not required if the total occupant load is 30 or less and this applies to all occupancies?
Comment:
This is in reference to a project in the City of Sunnyvale, California that has stated they only allow drinking fountain replacement in food establishments only as noted in the first
sentence above and that it was due to an official IAPMO interpretation UPC 18-23.
1. Yes. Section 415.2 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), states that “where food is consumed indoors, water stations shall be permitted to be substituted for drinking fountains”. This section applies only to restaurants, cafes, delicatessens and other eating and drinking establishments.
2. Yes. That same section of the 2015 UPC goes on to say, “bottle filling stations shall be permitted to be substituted for drinking fountains up to 50 percent of the requirements for drinking fountains”.
3. Yes. Section 415.2 of the 2015 UPC also states that, “Drinking fountains shall not be required for an occupant load of 30 or less”.
UPC 2018 422.1, 415.2, 206.0, 218.0
Topic: Minimum Number of Fixtures Allowed
1. Will a drinking fountain with high, low bubblers and bottle filler count as one (1) drinking fountain for the purpose of complying with Table 422.1?
2. Or can it be treated as three (3) separate fixtures?
Comment:
A project requires 6 drinking fountains per Table 422.1. architect is providing two (2) high/low drinking fountain/bottle filling station combination fixtures.
It is not clear if this would meet code. If treated as separate fixtures, they satisfy Table 422.1 with four (4) bubblers and (2) bottle filling stations since Section 415.2 allows bottle filling stations to substitute up to 50% of the drinking fountains required. However, based on the definitions of "drinking fountain" and "plumbing fixture", since this is one device it seems that it should be treated as a whole and only count it as one (1) drinking fountain. In this specific case, since they provided two (2), it seems they would need to provide four (4) more drinking fountains.
Yes. Drinking fountains* that have a single set of components, i.e. compressor, drain, water connection, etc., and are manufactured, tested and listed per Section 415.0 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code as a single unit are considered one fixture.
2. See answer 1
* Drinking Fountain. A plumbing fixture connected to the potable water distribution system and sanitary drainage system that provides drinking water in a flowing stream so that the user can consume water directly from the fixture without the use of accessories. Drinking fountains should also incorporate a bottle filling station and can incorporate a water filter and a cooling system for chilling the drinking water.
UPC 2015 422.1, Table 422.1
1. If these areas are for the use of the residents only, are these required to be treated as assembly use areas relative to the plumbing fixture counts in Section 422.1 and Table 422.1?
2. Can these be treated as accessory areas to the residential occupancy spaces, such that they would not be required to include a specific number of plumbing fixtures per Section 422 and Table 422.1 as independent assembly occupancy areas?
Comment:
The proposal would be to provide fixtures in these areas only for the convenience of the occupants, but not specifically to the number required by Table 422.1.
Conditions:
The project is a high-rise Group R-2 residential building. The building will include plumbing fixtures for the residents in each residential unit. The building also includes amenity spaces for the residents and include fitness spaces, pool deck, and similar areas. These areas are not open to the public and serve the residents only. These amenity spaces are loaded as assembly occupancy per the building code.
1. Fitness rooms, swimming pools and similar types of common areas are not considered part of an R-2 occupancy as shown in Table 422.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code. These assembly areas most closely fall within the parameters of an A-3 occupancy. Dependent upon the occupant load for each area, a restroom or restrooms meeting the requirements found in Section 422.2 for a single toilet facility or Table 422.1, A-3 for separate facilities would be used to determine the number of fixtures needed.
2. No. These spaces are not part of the residential units and would be classified as A-3 occupancy per Table 422.1
UPC 2015 408.3
Topic: Individual Shower and Tub Shower Combination Control Valves
1. Does the statement noting that the heater thermostats shall not be considered a suitable control for meeting this provision imply that there needs to be an additional device (ie a thermostatic mixing valve)somewhere on the hot water supply line to the tub/shower valve which will modulate the hot water supply temperature automatically to deliver a preset maximum hot water delivery temperature to the hot port of the tub/shower valve regardless of the thermostat setting at the water heater?
2. Or, does the code allow the system to simply have a water heater (with its standard temperature controls), supplying hot water to the tub shower valve, as long as the tub/shower valve is pressure balanced or thermostatically controlled, and has a temperature limit stop?
Comment:
This section states, near the bottom: Handle position stops shall be provided and adjusted per the manufacturers instructions to deliver a maximum mixed water setting of 120 degrees F. It then states that "The water heater thermostat shall not be considered a suitable control for meeting the provision."
I'm not entirely clear as to how to interpret the above statement. Limit stops on tub/shower valves are typically simple mechanical mixers, which introduce a fixed amount of cold water at all times. So assuming the system is set up properly in the beginning, the tub/shower valve will maintain 120 degrees maximum at its initial hot water heater delivery temperature, combined with the limit stop setting. However, in the event that the heater thermostat adjustment is later increased, or the heater malfunctions, the maximum hot water temperature discharged from the valve could increase above 120 degrees F.
1. No. Per Section 408.3 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code, the only acceptable means of tempering water for individual showers is with a point of use device meeting the requirements found in ASSE 1016 or ASME A112.18.1/CSA B125.1. A remote tempering device meeting the requirements found in ASSE 1069, may be used for gang showers, when there is a single water supply to the fixtures.
2. Yes. Water heaters provide hot water at temperatures ranging from 120°F to 210°F.* Hot water falling within those parameters may be delivered to the shower or tub/shower where a point of use device meeting ASSE 1016 or ASME A112.18.1/CSA B125.1 shall temper the water to a maximum 120°F.
Chapter 2 – Definitions
Hot Water. Water at a temperature exceeding or equal to 120°F (49°C).
Water Heater or Hot Water Heating Boiler. An appliance designed primarily to supply hot water for domestic or commercial purposes and equipped with automatic controls limiting water temperature to a maximum of 210°F
UPC 2015 402.10, 604.5
1. Are traps and control stops with water supplies for lavatories in cabinets required to be accessible or readily accessible?
2. If a drawer in a vanity has to be removed to access the lavatory connections does the installation meet UPC requirements?
3. If the answer to #2 is yes, what code section applies?
Comment:
We have been asked to install residential apartment lavatories that have pull out drawers instead of traditional swing open cabinet doors (see picture). The drawer will be required to be removed to access the p-trap and supply stops.
1. Per Section 402.10 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code, fixtures having concealed slip joint connections must be accessible by means of an access panel or utility space of not less than 12”x 12”. Fixture control valves and supplies or connectors, other than flexible connectors (see Section 604.5), installed to meet the requirements found in Section 606.3 shall also be accessible*.
2. Yes, if the drawer, when removed from the cabinet, produces a minimum 12”x 12” access opening.
3. Section 402.10.
Section 203.0 Accessible. Where applied to a fixture, connection, appliance, or equipment, “accessible” means having access thereto, but which first may require the removal of an access panel, door, or similar obstruction.
UPC 2018 422.2 & 422.4.1
Topic: Minimum Number of Required Fixture
Given: 6 story building, 1 through 5 are B and 6 is A-3 occupancy, Building load exceeds 50.
1. Are fixture requirements based on the total occupant load?
2. Are fixture requirements based the occupant load of each floor separately?
3. If calculated per individual floor would exception 3 of 422.4.1 apply when the occupant load does not exceed 50?
4. If single use toilet facilities are provided for a floor or the entire building, are urinals no longer required, reducing the number of fixtures?
5. Assume level 6 has insufficient fixture. Are the fixture located on level 5 (based on level 5 occupancy) allowed to make up the shortfall?
6. Assume level 6 has insufficient fixture. Can the additional fixture be located on the 5th level?
1. Yes. Section 422.1 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code states that the total occupant load and occupancy classification shall be determined in accordance with the building code. In the submitted example, the total occupant load for floors one through five would be calculated as a “B” Occupancy with the understanding that the occupant(s) of the building would permit access to the restrooms on all floors. The requirements found in Section 422.4.1 would apply in this instance. The total occupant load for the sixth floor would be calculated as an “A-3” occupancy.
2. As stated in question one, a single occupant load may be used for all five floors of the “B” Occupancy, if the restrooms are accessible to all occupants of the building. In the event that each floor has a different tenant and access to restrooms are restricted to occupants of that floor, the total occupant load for each floor would be required.
3. No. Section 422.4.1 would only apply if the restrooms on each floor were accessible to the occupants of floors one through five.
4. A toilet facility is defined as “a room or space containing not less than one lavatory and one water closet”. A urinal is not required for this type of installation.
5. No. Floor six is an “A-3” Occupancy and would require adequate fixtures for the total occupant load for that floor.
6. No. All fixtures would be required to be located on the sixth floor.
UPC 2018 404.2
When a bathtub overflow is not attached to the bathtub but is provided through other means, is water allowed to rise in the overflow, when the stopper is closed?
Comment:
Is the concern that the overflow water may reenter the bathtub at the overflow hole? If this is a safety concern, why is it allowed for water to be present from the waste to the tee when the stopper is closed as per triplever style bath wastes overflows? (Refer to attached product 314TRIP-16CP) These bath waste overflows have a plunger that closes the waste tube off, however since the plunger is hollow, it still allows the overflow water to drain. See attached New product Concept Sketch. If possible, I would like to propose a change to this clause to allow for the new product sketch but I need to understand the rationale behind it first.
No. Section 404.2 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code states that “where a fixture is provided with an overflow, the waste shall be so arranged that the standing water in the fixture shall not rise in the overflow where the stopper is closed or remain in the overflow where the fixture is empty.”
Note: The OS&B bathtub waste & overflow is tested and listed by CSA not IAPMO. The notation that it meets the UPC does not make the product UPC Code Compliant.
UPC 2018 404.2
Follow-Up to UPC 20-59: In a comment unrelated to the question asked in UPC 20-59, you stated: “The OS&B bathtub waste & overflow is tested and listed by CSA not IAPMO. The notation that it meets the UPC does not make the product UPC Code Compliant.”
1. Are you saying that in general (not about the W&O), just because it is noted on a document the item is UPC compliant, doesn't make it so?
2. Are you saying the Waste and Overflow assembly in the attached document is not UPC compliant?
3. If not, why not?
Comment:
As part of their service CSA verifies Code compliance and in their opinion 314TRIP-16CP is UPC Code compliant, therefore the “cCSAus Meets UPC” marking on the product. This is similar to IAPMO providing a UPCc marking indicating Code compliance to UPC and NPC of Canada.
Just want to understand what is being said in the Note.
1. Yes. A notation on a product flier or an on-line advertisement does not necessarily mean that a product complies with the Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC). Per Section 301.2 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code, a product would be considered UPC compliant when it is tested to applicable standards by an accredited listing agency, suitably marked, complies with all relevant sections of the Uniform Plumbing Code and is approved for installation by the Authority Having Jurisdiction.
2. No. If the product conforms to the requirements listed above it would be UPC compliant.
UPC 2015 402.6.1
1. Does 402.6.1 require an ABS closet ring be cemented to closet bend or stub before rough inspection is called?
Comment:
The section does not say closet ring shall be cemented to the closet bend before rough inspection is called. I failed an inspection because the closet ring was not cemented to the closet bend for rough inspection and this code was sited.
No. Section 402.6.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code states that, ”closet bends or stubs shall be cut off so as to present a smooth surface even with the top of closet ring before rough inspection”. It does not say that the closet ring must be cut off and glued to the closet bend or stub prior to the rough in inspection.
Note: Good plumbing practice would suggest that the optimum installation would be for the bottom of the closet ring to rest on the top of the finished floor. This would provide a suitable surface for a gasket, washer or setting compound to create the water tight seal between the fixture and closet ring as prescribed in Section 402.6.
UPC 2018 422.0, 422.2.1, 422.2.2
Topic: Minimum Number of Required Fixtures. Single Use Toilet Facilities. Family or Assisted-Use Toilet Facilities.
When calculating the minimum required toilets for males and females, would a single use toilet facility be counted for males or females or both or neither?
Comment:
I would like to know how to apply the general intent of the referenced code sections, as well as how to apply it for calculating minimum plumbing facilities. The UPC recognizes single use, family and assisted use toilet facilities, which are required to be identified with signage indicating use by either sex.
No. Commercial buildings with occupant loads large enough to require separate male and female toilet facilities shall be provided with the minimum number of fixtures as prescribed in Table 422.1 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code. The installation of a single use toilet facility would be in addition to the minimum required by Code.
UPC 2018 418.3(3)
Topic: Location of Floor Drains
In a commercial application, does this apply strictly to "laundry rooms", or rather are they required for any room containing a functional washing machine?
Comment:
Section states in part: "Floor drains shall be installed in... Laundry rooms in commercial buildings and common laundry facilities in multi-family dwelling buildings."
See attached for reference. This would technically be a Janitor's Closet containing clothes washing services.
Yes. Section 418.3(3) of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code states that a floor drain is required in “laundry rooms in commercial buildings and common laundry facilities in multi-family dwelling buildings”. The attached illustration shows a washer and dryer in a laundry room* within a commercial building. The requirements found in Section 418.3(3) would apply.
* Wikipedia Definition
Laundry Room – A laundry room (also called utility room) is a room where clothes are washed and dried.
UPC 2015 411.3
Topic: Water Closet Seats
Please provide interpretation or clarification of Plumbing Code Section 411.3 with regard to electric hygienic water closet seats.
The installation of personal hygiene devices for water closets is not addressed in the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), and would therefore not be code compliant without approval by the Authority Having Jurisdiction. The installation requirements of these devices was first introduced into the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code. Section 411.4 of that document states “water closets with integral personal hygiene devices shall comply with ASME A112.4.2/CSA B45.16 - Personal Hygiene Devices for Water Closets. The title and scope of this standard suggests that these devices are intended to be used for private not public installations.
UPC 2018 422.4.1
Topic: Access to Toilet Facilities
1. In a multi-story building is it permissible to group required bathroom facilities on alternating floors as long as the total occupant load for both floors is used to determine the required fixture type and quantity?
Yes. The minimum number of fixtures required shall be determined by applying the requirements found in Section 422.1 and Table 422.1 of the 2015 Uniform Plumbing Code. Section 422.4.1 states that “in multi-story buildings, accessibility to the required toilet facilities shall not exceed one vertical story”. Additionally, Section 422.4 requires toilet facilities for employees and customers in other than shopping malls or centers shall have a maximum travel distance not to exceed 500 feet.
UPC 2018 422.1, 415.2, 206.0, 218.0
Topic: Minimum Number of Fixtures Allowed
1. Will a drinking fountain with high, low bubblers and bottle filler count as one (1) drinking fountain for the purpose of complying with Table 422.1?
2. Or can it be treated as three (3) separate fixtures?
Yes. Drinking fountains* that have a single set of components, i.e. compressor, drain, water connection, etc., and are manufactured, tested and listed per Section 415.0 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code as a single unit are considered one fixture.
2. See answer 1
UPC 2015 402.6.1
1. Does 402.6.1 require the closet ring be permanently connected to closet bend or stub before rough inspection is called?
No. Section 402.6.1 of the Uniform Plumbing Code states that, ”closet bends or stubs shall be cut off so as to present a smooth surface even with the top of closet ring before rough inspection”. It does not say that the closet ring must be permanently connected to the closet bend or stub prior to the rough in inspection.
UPC 2018 409.4
Topic: Limitations of Hot Water in Bathtubs and Whirlpool Bathtubs
Does the use of an ASSE 1017/CSA B125 master mixing valve, installed downstream of the water heaters/boilers in the mechanical room, supplying hot water at 110°F directly to multiple whirlpool tubs meet the intent of Section 409.4?
No. Section 409.4 of the 2018 Uniform Plumbing Code specifically states that “the maximum hot water temperature from the bathtub or whirlpool bathtub filler shall be limited to 120°F by a device that complies with ASSE 1070/ASME A112.1070/CSA B125.70.”
UPC 2021 406.3.2 (4)
Topic: Temperature Limitation, Shower and Tub-Shower Control Valves
1. Why is this limited to a water heater conforming to ASSE 1084?
2. Why isn't ASSE 1082, Performance requirements for water heaters with integral temperature control devices for hot water distribution systems also an option?
1. A water heater conforming to ASSE 1084, as found in Section 408.3.2 of the 2021 Uniform Plumbing Code (UPC), is a point of use water heater. Per Section 1.2.1 of ASSE 1084, “This water heater is intended to supply tempered water at point of use in order to reduce the risks of scalding”. These devices limit water temperature to a maximum of 120°F.
2. A water heater listed to ASSE 1082, per Section 1.2 of the standard “is for water heaters that control the outlet temperature to specific limits and are installed within the hot water distribution system but not at point-of-use”. Water heaters listed to this standard limit water temperature to a maximum of 125°F, which exceeds the water temperatures permitted by Sections 407.3, 408.3.2, 409.4 and 410.3 of the 2021 UPC.
UPC 2018 415.2
Topic: Drinking Fountain Alternatives
Are any of the following an approved “Water Station” that may be used as an alternative to drinking fountains?
1. Water dispenser (portable units typically found in homes and offices with refillable water bottles but not connected to potable water distribution line).
2. Soda fountains that also dispense water as one of the options (typically found in fast food restaurants).
3. Bottle filling station.
4. Is the statement in this code section, "where food is consumed indoors", intended for restaurants only (A2) or can this be for other occupancies that have indoor eating like lunch rooms inside other types of occupancies like E, M, or B?
1. No. Section 206.0 of the 2018 UPC defines a drinking fountain as “A plumbing fixture connected to the potable water distribution system and sanitary drainage system that provides drinking water in a flowing steam so that the user can consume water directly from the fixture without use of accessories…”.
2. Section 415.2 specifically states that “where food is consumed indoors, water stations shall be permitted to be substituted for drinking fountains.” Restaurant soda fountains in with water dispensers would fall into the category of a water station.
3. Per Section 415.2, “…Bottle filling stations shall be permitted to be substituted for drinking fountains up to 50 percent of the requirement for drinking fountains.”
4. Yes. Although other types of occupancies may have a sink for drinking water in their employee’s breakrooms, the public would not have access to its use.
UPC 2015 408.3, 407.3, 409.4, 410.3
Topic: Shower and Tub/Shower Combination Control Valves
1. Is a master mixer valve required at the building water heater in addition to the required temperature limiting valves furnished at all locations listed in the code?
A thermostatic mixing valve is not required at the water heater.
• 407.3 limitation of hot water temperature at lavatories is accomplished by utilizing an ASSE 1070 compliant temperature limiting device.
• Shower and tub-shower combinations are required to comply with ASSE 1016 or ASME 1069 to limit hot water temperature.
• Bathtubs and whirlpool bathtub shall limit hot water temperature in accordance with ASSE 1070 or CSA B125.3
Temperature limitation is not intended to be controlled by water heater thermostat. Limitation of hot water temperature is intended to be controlled at point of use.
UPC 2018 406.1, 301.2
Topic: Decorative Water Fountains
1. Does the UPC regulate the installation of decorative water fountains?
2. If yes, are decorative water fountains required to be third-party listed in accordance with Section 301.2?
3. If yes, are the pipe and fitting materials used in decorative fountains required to comply with those listed in Table 604.1 and Table 701.2 for water supply and waste, respectively?
1. Yes, the UPC regulates the installation of decorative water fountains and similar fixtures which require water, waste connections or both. These water features must be submitted to the Authority Having Jurisdiction prior to installation.
2. No, many of these ornamental fixtures are built on the job.
3. All materials used to complete water and/or waste connections must meet recognized standards set forth by the Uniform Plumbing Code. Materials must be installed to provide backflow protection and trap seal protection.
UPC 2012 403.4
Are the restrooms in a church considered to be serving the transient public?
Comment:
The restrooms are only available for use when the church is open for services and parishioner activities. These are scheduled and therefore predictable periods of restroom access.
The AHJ is categorizing the parishioners as transient.
Our contention is that although the restrooms are available for use by the church parishioners, they are not available or intended for use by the general public.
Yes, The code states “but not limited to” with examples of lavatories intended to serve the public with the intent of limited time for public access.
UPC 2003 414.1
UPC 2006 413.1
UPC 2009 413.1
UPC 2012 421.2
UPC 2015 407.3
Topic: Limitation of Hot Water Temperature for Public Lavatories
Is it the intent of section 407.3 to require the device solely at the fixture or can a device be in the system to control multiple or all fixtures?
The code requires the hot water at a public lavatory to be limited to 120-degree F maximum. This has to be accomplished with a device that is listed to ASSE 1070 or CSA B125.3. This device can control multiple fixtures and could be a master tempering valve, a tempering valve at the lavatory, or even the faucet itself, as long as they are listed to ASSE 1070 or CSA B125.3
UPC 2015 408.6 exception 2
Topic: Shower Compartments
1. Does the exception for shower receptors of 30 x 60” include a 1-piece shower enclosures of the same dimension?
Yes. Section 408.6 of the 2015 UPC, Exception (2) permits the installation of a shower receptor having dimensions of not less than 30 inches in width and 60 inches in length. This allows the replacement of a bathtub with a walk in shower without meeting the minimum shower requirements found in Section 408.6. Listed one piece shower receptors meeting the dimensions found in Exception (2) would be acceptable.
UPC 2003 807.4
UPC 2006 807.4
UPC 2009 807.4
UPC 2012 414.3, 807.4
UPC 2015 414.3, 807.3
Topic: Drainage Connection
1. Is the Dishwasher Air Gap fitting required to protect the public water supply?
2. Is the Dishwasher Air Gap fitting required to assure no possibility of a grey-water siphon from the p-trap into the dishwasher?
3. Is the Dishwasher Air Gap fitting required to prevent black-water sewage from entering a dishwasher?
1. No. Section 414.1 of the 2012 Uniform Plumbing Code requires domestic or commercial dishwashing machines to comply with the applicable standards referenced in Table 1401.1. Domestic dishwashers are to be tested and listed to UL 749, which requires compliance with ASSE 1006. Section 1.3.4 of ASSE 1006 states, “Potable water supplies to the unit shall be protected against contamination by means of air gaps or other acceptable devices. This requirement applies to the supplying of potable water to all accessories such as dispensers and injectors as well as the washing machine.” Dishwashers not listed to UL 749 and ASSE 1006 must be approved by the Authority Having Jurisdiction prior to installation as prescribed in Chapter 3. The drainage air gap fitting described in Section 807.4, is intended to prevent backflow of waste water from the kitchen sink into the washing compartment of the dishwasher in the event of a stoppage in the kitchen sink or waste line.
2. Kitchen sink waste is not gray water* but would be considered sewage**. The drainage air gap fitting for a residential dishwasher is intended to prevent backflow of waste water from the kitchen sink into the washing compartment of the dishwasher, in the event of a stoppage in the kitchen sink or waste line.
3. Yes. See #2
*Gray Water. Untreated wastewater that has not come into contact with toilet waste, kitchen sink waste, dishwasher waste or similarly contaminated sources. Gray water includes wastewater from bathtubs, showers, lavatories, clothes washers, and laundry tubs. Also known as grey water, graywater, and greywater.
**Sewage. Liquid waste containing animal or vegetable matter in suspension or solution and that may include liquids containing chemicals in solution
UPC 2018 409.4
Topic: Limitation of Hot Water in Bathtubs and Whirlpool Bathtub
Would the hand held shower on a whirlpool tub faucet require a mixing valve listed to ASSE 1016 or does a ASSE 1070 listed limiting device on the tub faucet take care of that hand shower?
The ASSE 1070 should be used to comply. ASSE 1016 is applicable to stand-up shower enclosures to prevent thermal shock when standing in the water under the shower head.
UPC 2018 408.9
Topic: Location of Valves and Heads
Does a shower valve have to be accessible without the bather standing in the showers spray? Will a shower layout meet Code section 408.9, if the shower head must be turned or moved each time a bather turns on the valve in order for the bather to not get wet?
The intent is not to position the shower spray directly at the shower compartment entrance. Positioning the shower head on the side wall allows bather to adjust the temperature of the water without getting wet. The potential of thermal shock could cause a sudden reaction by the bather, causing a slip or fall. The shower presented in attachment is code compliant.